Current:Home > NewsSan Francisco has lots of self-driving cars. They're driving first responders nuts -Financium
San Francisco has lots of self-driving cars. They're driving first responders nuts
View
Date:2025-04-16 00:43:11
A battle has been brewing in San Francisco over driverless cars. Hundreds of the autonomous vehicles have been roaming city streets over the past couple of years and on Thursday, California's transportation regulator will decide whether to allow even more on the road.
San Francisco's police and fire departments are urging the regulator to say no – they say they've tallied 55 incidents where self-driving cars have impeded rescue operations in just the last six months. The incidents include running through yellow emergency tape, blocking firehouse driveways and refusing to move for first responders.
"Our folks cannot be paying attention to an autonomous vehicle when we've got ladders to throw," San Francisco Fire Chief Jeanine Nicholson said Monday in a public meeting about the issue. "I am not anti-technology, I am pro-safety."
The autonomous vehicles are run by Cruise, which is owned by General Motors, and Waymo, which is owned by Google parent Alphabet. Some of the cars have human safety drivers, others are completely empty. Select passengers can hail rides with the vehicles, like a taxi.
Waymo says it has a permit for 250 vehicles and it deploys around 100 at any given time. Cruise says it runs 100 cars in San Francisco during the day and 300 at night. During a July earnings call, Cruise CEO Kyle Vogt said the city could handle several thousand more driverless cars.
Both companies have urged the California Public Utilities Commission, CPUC, to allow for more cars and at all times of the day. They're also asking to deploy more vehicles in other California cities, including Los Angeles and Santa Monica.
The companies say driverless vehicles are safer than human-driven ones when it comes to passenger safety and that none of the incidents cited by the fire and police departments have resulted in passenger injury. Neither company has directly answered why their technology is responding to emergency vehicles this way.
"We have demonstrated our deep willingness and longtime commitment to work in partnership with California state, SF city and first responders," said Waymo spokesperson Katherine Barna. Cruise spokesperson Drew Pusateri said: "Autonomous vehicles are used by thousands of California residents and have a strong safety record."
Fire Chief Nicholson said that when the driverless cars get in the way of and slow down emergency vehicles, they pose a threat to public safety.
"Every second can make a difference. A fire can double is size in one minute," she said during the meeting. "If we are blocked by an autonomous vehicle that could lead to more harm to the people in that building, to the housing overall and to my first responders."
The fire department has also documented driverless cars rolling over the firehoses used to put out blazes. In one of those episodes, captured on police body camera footage obtained by Mission Local, a driverless car approached the scene of a massive fire in a residential neighborhood and inched slowly toward the firehose as frustrated first responders did all they could to stop it.
"No! Go back!" they yelled. "It doesn't know what to do!"
Several police officer and firefighter associations and unions in the Bay Area have written letters to the California Public Utilities Commission urging the regulator to hold off on allowing more driverless cars on the road, according to Mission Local.
"While we all applaud the advancements in technology, we must not be in such a rush that we forget the human element and the effects such technology unchecked can create dangerous situations," wrote the San Francisco Police Officers Association in June. The groups asked the Commission "not to approve the application for autonomous vehicles until more research is done."
Hundreds of California residents have also submitted public comments to the regulator. The vast majority say they oppose adding more driverless cars to San Francisco's streets. Many of the commenters quoted the words of Fire Chief Nicholson when she told the LA Times in June that driverless cars are "not ready for prime time."
veryGood! (3974)
Related
- Nevada attorney general revives 2020 fake electors case
- Former Missouri officer who fatally shot a Black man plans another appeal and asks for bond
- Lobbyist gets 2 years in prison for Michigan marijuana bribery scheme
- Which Republicans voted against Jim Jordan's speaker bid Wednesday — and who changed sides?
- Trump's 'stop
- Kosovo asks for more NATO-led peacekeepers along the border with Serbia
- Erik Larson’s next book closely tracks the months leading up to the Civil War
- SEC coaches are more accepting of youthful mistakes amid roster engagement in the portal era
- The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
- Search continues for inmate who escaped from Houston courthouse amid brawl in courtroom
Ranking
- The Louvre will be renovated and the 'Mona Lisa' will have her own room
- The pope’s absolute power, and the problems it can cause, are on display in 2 Vatican trials
- Democrat Katrina Christiansen announces her 2nd bid for North Dakota US Senate seat
- Netflix drops new cast photos for live action 'The Last Airbender' with Daniel Dae Kim
- New Mexico governor seeks funding to recycle fracking water, expand preschool, treat mental health
- A sweeping gun bill aimed at tightening firearm laws passes in the Massachusetts House
- Corrupt ex-Baltimore police officer asks for compassionate prison release, citing cancer diagnosis
- Drone attack on base hosting US troops intercepted in Iraq, heightening fears of a broader conflict
Recommendation
Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
James Harden skips 76ers practice, coach Nick Nurse unsure of what comes next
Hitting the snooze button won't hurt your health, new sleep research finds
Simu Liu Reveals His Parents Accidentally Took His Recreational Drugs While House Sitting
South Korean president's party divided over defiant martial law speech
Aaron Nola tosses a gem, Phillies crush Diamondbacks to take commanding NLCS lead
Former official accused in Las Vegas journalist killing hires lawyer, gets trial date pushed back
German soccer club Mainz suspends player for ‘unacceptable’ social media post about Israel-Hamas war